Our Shaped by Dog podcast is designed to be heard or viewed. If you are able, we encourage you to listen to the audio or watch the video, as each includes nuances of emotion and emphasis that might not come through on the written word. Transcripts are generated from the audio, then humans review with love and care, and then there's a double check by our dogs. If you are quoting in print, please check the audio first for full context. Thank you!

Speaker Key

SG Susan Garrett



Something you may not know about me is I love kids. I am particularly keen on kids who have an interest in dogs and those who are curious about training dogs well, I'm all in.

And so, when a 10th grader from Louisiana asked me to answer a few questions to help her out with a school assignment, I said, “Let's go!”


Hi, I am Susan Garrett. Welcome to Shaped by Dog. When I got these questions from Finya, I said,
“Hey, do you mind if I shared this on a podcast?” And she thought that would be a lot of fun.

I thought it was important because I think they're great questions, but I also think as a community of
dog lovers, it's super important that we have a pulse on the feelings and the thought processes and the
curiosities of an up-and-coming dog trainer.


Now, I'm going to preface this by saying I don't know Finya personally, I did meet her when I was in
Houston competing at an agility trial there. Her Australian Shepherd Vapor came second to This! in one
of the classes that we ran down there.

So, I know she has an interest in dog agility. Obviously, she loves dogs, and she has a curiosity to
learn more, and that's why she reached out to me.


And so that's all the background that I know, and here are the questions that Finya had for me. Number
one, “What are the beneficial factors you see in positive reinforcement?” And I had to ask Finya for
some follow up information on some of these questions. But that one I'm like, how do I answer that?


To me, asking what the benefits of positive reinforcement, is like asking what's the benefit of oxygen.
It's just that important. You know, when most people start out training a dog, reinforcement is like a tool
in the toolbox that we can use reinforcement as a lure to get behavior, for prompt behavior. We can
use reinforcement to reinforce a behavior well done. But there's other tools we might have in that


Now for me, as my dog training journey evolved, reinforcement became less of a tool and more of who
I was. So, it's a lens that I look through the world with. It may have started with my love and passion in
helping my dogs to be brilliant, but it's something I strive to look through every single day in every
single circumstance.

Not just with dogs, but with people, with everybody I deal with in my life. When you approach training
this way it creates a bond with your dog that is so deep because your primary focus is about how to
make this dog have an amazing life. How to help this dog have more freedoms.


Does the dog not have a great recall? Therefore, I have to keep her on leash? How can I use the
reinforcement in this dog's life? How can I manipulate environments?

How can I make sure that the dog has this clear understanding of what their name means? And that I
always want them to turn on a dime and fly back to me. And I want to do that only with reinforcement.


So, what are the benefits of reinforcement training? It allows you to always show up as your best self,
to be the most empathetic, the most self-aware, the kindest. The kind of person that anybody would
love to spend time with. The kind of person that the dog wakes up every morning and says, “She is my
person how awesome is that?!”

I think that's the benefits of reinforcement. In my world I believe that dogs are always doing the best
they can with the education we've given them in the environment that we've put them in.


So, if they make a mistake, they don't deserve punishment. They don't deserve us being frustrated or
disappointed by them because it would mean we are frustrated or disappointed in ourselves because
the dog is just who we made them to be.


And yes, people listening to this might say, “Oh, but I have a rescue dog therefore it's somebody else's
baggage.” Well, your rescue dog is doing the best they can with the education they've been given in
the kind of upside down, topsy-turvy life that they've had to live.

That dog needs more grace than any dog. I mean, I think all dogs need maximum amount of grace, but
if you're going to dial it down for anybody, it should be for a rescue dog.


And so, your rescue dog is a reflection of your ability to bring out the best in a rescue dog without
hanging onto baggage, without saying, “Well, this one need to be trained differently because he was
raised differently.” That's a very long answer to “What are the benefits that I see in reinforcement?” It's
just, it's life. It's everything.


Next question, “Where do you draw the line between training tools, techniques and abuse?” I used to
say the dog is the one who will tell us that what's being abusive or what's being unkind.

But the truth is, there are dogs who can look like they want to leave training and they're being trained
with a cookie but maybe the application of reinforcement is so confusing for the dog because of the
limited experience or mechanics of the trainer. That dog just looks like they're afraid and they want to
get out of here.


Likewise, there are dogs trained with prong collars, chain collars, electric collars that look like they're
having a great time because their trainer has this great gift of timing and maybe long, lengthy

So, I don't believe it's solely the dog who will tell us.


You know, when I first started teaching classes here, I think it was 1998, and I knew I had a very small
window that I could teach, I still had a full-time job. And I knew people who came to my puppy class
were going to go off to other classes in the neighborhood. And no other classes were going to have the
approach to training that we had here. So, I knew those dogs were going to leave here and get collar


And so, part of our early curriculum was shaping the puppy's tolerance to a tug on their collar in a
playful way. They're in the middle of tugging and you'll just tug on their collar a little bit, little bit more
tugging, little tugging on the collar till eventually you could pop on the collar and the dog would still tug
and they wouldn't stop tugging. And so that dog left here and went to another class and if somebody
popped them with a correction, the dog's ears would still stay up and they'd still stay bright.


As long as a person doing the correcting wasn't also adding harsh emotional trauma to the dog, the dog probably would look happy. But does that mean that training with physical corrections or aversives of any kind is something that everybody should do if they do it the right way? I don't think so.


It's such a loaded question. It's a great question Finya, but the truth is any dog training tool can be
abusive. Dogs have been abused well just on a flat collar and leash. Dogs can be spun around while in
a body harness. Any tool. You can throw a clicker at a dog and hurt them, maybe hit them in the eye.
Okay, it'd have to be really heavy clicker. Maybe you whipped it hard, and you got them in a soft spot, I
don't know.


Pretty much any tool in dog training can be abusive. So more than the tools themselves being abusive,
I think it's the intention of the human. You know, some trainers believe that every dog needs to know
“they have to do it or else.” Every dog will have their ‘come to Jesus’ moment where they really need to
be you know, dominated because that's the way dog training is.


And I've got to tell you, I've been a professional dog trainer for more than 30 years. I have yet to find
that. I have yet to find the dog that doesn't respond to the manipulation of environment and good oldfashioned reinforcement-based dog training. I have yet to find that dog.

And I have trained in our online programs, tens of thousands of dogs. And I've trained thousands
before I started teaching in the online space. So, I believe that it's the intention of the person. If you are
trying to do something to create the potential for pain in a dog, then that is in my opinion abusive. And it
could be emotional pain. It could be like agility competitors who yell at the dog or for knocking a bar or
picking them up and carrying them out of the ring. I just don't think that's necessary.


But I promise you there was a point in my life I did pick up dogs and carry them out of the ring. The
more I've focused on being a curious dog trainer and focused on all the different ways I could use
reinforcement in my training, the less I've needed to use any form of punishment or a timeout in my


Alright, this is a question that I had to ask for more clarification on. I guess just because probably
Finya’s background and mine are so different. But I'm glad she asked it because I love to be opened up
to different insights. I love to become aware and to different backgrounds of where people are coming


“Have you noticed beginners in the dog sport world being confused or scared due to what they've
heard or learned from the public and their ideas that training is abuse?”

So, when I first read that I thought, well, I know some like PETA people think any kind of dog training is abusive. But I thought, rather than assume that I'd ask for more clarification.


And so, what Finya said was, “Several people I have met who started training dogs were so used to the
way of heavy handling the dogs where they would pop them very hard, or even hit the dog. What I'm
asking is, have you ever helped a beginner and they were so afraid to do it wrong and possibly have
people think they were forcing or hurting the dog?”

So, as you can imagine Finya having listened to this episode so far, that's not something that I teach. In
1988, I was introduced to collar corrections on a chain collar. And I saw a lot of the methodology that
you are talking about now through the late Eighties and early Nineties.


But by 1993, I had moved away from that. By 1996, it was gone. And so, have I seen young people
who are afraid to train because they're afraid of making mistakes? I've seen some really poor coaching.
Regardless if you're teaching a young person to correct a dog or apply an aversive. Which I just can't
imagine doing that.

Because what is the message that we're sending to the young people? “When something that's weaker
than us does something we don't like, we have the right to do this to them.” I just think that's such a
horrible message.


You know, we're living in an awakening time when we can be empathetic to everybody's, every being's
needs, every living being on this planet. And so, I just can't imagine trying to teach a young person how
to apply an aversive to a dog so that they will listen to you. It's just not something that I would like to

But I have seen even reinforcement-based people coaching in a way that makes those people feel less
than. I know 25 years ago I was one of those people. And so, if you're training dogs and you have a
great skill and a great love of training dogs, I encourage you to become equally passionate about
reaching people, coaching in a way that makes them feel better rather than patting or feeding your own


And so, a lot of times young people get afraid to try something, even if it's a reinforced-based process
because they're afraid that failing isn't a good thing. Failing should be embraced. Nobody should ever
be afraid to try anything that is going to bring more joy to a dog's life. Okay, Finya’s next questions.


“What are your thoughts on people who use electric collars, prong collars, and leash pops?” You know
my thoughts on the people are, everybody's welcome here. I love curious people who want to learn
how to apply reinforcement in a way that they don't ever have to use electric collars, leash pops, or
prong collars

And as I mentioned, it's possible. It doesn't matter what your training, it doesn't matter who will insist
I'm wrong. There are more and more and more dog trainers out there that will prove to you that I am
right, that you don't need that.


If you are a reinforcement-based dog trainer, the worst thing you could do is make somebody who
comes to you training with an electric collar or leash pops or prong collars, the worst thing you could do
is make them feel judged. Because you can never help somebody while you're judging them. You just
can't. You're going to put them in their back brain. They're going to get defensive. They're going to feel
embarrassed. They're going to feel less than.


So, if you are a person who currently uses any form of a correction, a physical correction with your dog,
I hope that you're curious enough to do a deep dive into some of these older podcasts that I have here.

And be sure to ask a question, come over to YouTube and leave me a comment and ask a question
knowing that you're in a place of safety. There are no questions that you could ask that you will ever be
judged for asking.


And final question from Finya. “When dealing with a dog who does not respond as well as you would
like to positive reinforcement, what do you turn to for help?” Alright, number one thing I turn to for help
Finya is my video. Because dog training is a mechanical skill in that a dog can only be as good as the
trainer's mechanics.

And so, I'll look at my mechanics and now maybe even get somebody else to look at them and say,
“What do you think I was trying to achieve here?” Because if you can't see it, my dog couldn't see it


I'll then look at my training plan. Have I broken things down into the small enough pieces? Where was
the confusion? Is there joy? Did I get a joyful dog to start? And was I training in an environment that
was suitable for that dog's age and stage of training?

Meaning if I had a young Jack Russell puppy and I wanted to work on a recall, I wouldn't go to a bunny
farm for that
. Because the environment would be screaming the puppy's name. Environmental has all
the power until we, through our great use of reinforcement, turn off the power of the environment,


So, if I had a dog who wasn't responding to reinforcement, number one it would be the health of the
dog. Make sure get that dog to the veterinarian. Make sure there's no way that that dog's in pain. Okay,
so that's my number one.


Number two is my video. Number three is my training plan. And then number four would be my mentor.
If I still am stumped, I will go out and ask. I mean, that's how I got solutions to my young girl This! when
I just didn't know how to help her. I just started asking people whose opinion I respect in the dog
training world, “What do you think?” And lo and behold, I stumbled on nutrition is a big part of it.


And so that's all the questions. Finya, thank you for asking and thank you for agreeing to be part of the
podcast. And those of you who are listening, I'd love for you to jump over to YouTube, write some
comments to Finya. Encourage her to keep going on her journey in dog training and I'll see you next
time right here on Shaped by Dog.